From Thomas Gibson’s career fallout after an on-set altercation to Shamar Moore’s accidental steamy text to his mom and his decision to skip the show’s finale, the former Criminal Minds stars have lived stories as dramatic as their characters. While Mandy Patinkin rebuilt his career through Homeland and Jennifer Love Hewitt traded the BAU for 9-1-1, others stepped away from Hollywood altogether. Let’s watch the video to see where the team’s real-life stories have taken them.