Between rounds of Never Have I Ever, Sam recalls the infamous “boot incident,” Caitríona admits her phone once interrupted a scene with a nanny’s voice chiming in, and Richard confesses to accidentally slipping into a Southern drawl mid-performance. The laughter only grows when the cast roasts each other with scripted one-liners in the straight-face challenge—let’s watch the video to see who cracked first and which shocking confessions left everyone in stitches.